Quantcast

To chiro or not to chiro........

qb ant's picture
Posts
612
Member
1438 days
started by qb ant on February 22, 2006

Has anyone out there seen a chiroprator? I've always had lower back pain, so about 6 months ago I went to the back dr. - did the MRI and I have degenerative disc disease - did the pt - the cortison - the stetches, and so on. Nothing really helped. A friend talked me into seeing a chiropractor, and although very skeptical, I went. It's been about a month, and I really don't think it's helping at all. I have another appt. with the back dr., but my friend, who really believes in the chiro, says to give it more time. I think "time's up". Anyone with any experience?

Thanks for any help - Ant

"90% of the game is half mental" Yogi Berra

Triguy98's picture
Posts
2437
Member
1321 days
Triguy98 posted 2 years ago.

While I personally have never been to a chiro, my mom has been a lot.

She was in a BAD car accident in the mid 80s that messed her up. Got better, but another accident made it worse. Regular docs had her in braces and pain pills. Shed be passed out on the couch, barely able to move, etc. So she started going to a chiro. While shes not brand new, she doesnt need any pain meds or braces anymore. Shes definately a believer.

Life is short. Play hard and get dirty doing it.

fishAD83's picture
Posts
6
Member
1006 days
fishAD83 posted 2 years ago.

I have had quite a bit of experience with chiros, acutally the reverse of yours qb ant. My junior year of high school, I was the drum major of our marching band (the one standing on the podium waving her arms...) and working as a swim instructor. Long story short, I lost all feeling in my left hand. Went to my MD looking for PT or something along those lines. He passed it off as "growing pains." So we tried a chiro. My chiro did x-rays and a full eval (grip tests, etc.) and found out that I have nerve damage from undiagnosed scoliosis. My chiro has done wonders since then -- no pain, no numbness, no tingling. Amazing. To be fair -- my chiro has specialized in sports medicine. Try to find someone in your area with an emphasis in sports management, etc. They'll have better resources as far as allowing you to continue to train without exasperating the problem. Hope that helps! - Erin

[FONT=Tahoma]"Sow a thought and you reap an act; sow an act and you reap a habit; sow a habit and you reap a character; sow a character and you reap a destiny." - Samuel Smiles

qb ant's picture
Posts
612
Member
1438 days
qb ant posted 2 years ago.

Thanks guys-

The skeptic in me always gets the better of me. My chiro is also an avid runner. Although my md gave me one diagnosis, the chiro told me all my problems are in my neck which in turn affects my back - makes sense. Anyway, I'll give it some more time and see what happens.

Thanks again - Ant

"90% of the game is half mental" Yogi Berra

RV's picture
Posts
3354
Member
1402 days
RV posted 2 years ago.

I also have not gone to a chiro, but my wife does regularly go. She was kicked in back by her horse many years ago and going to the chiro really helps. It does take some time and good one. She swears by it. Tho she went to a couple to find one that was effective.

RV

It takes a long time to get good. - Scott Molina
Slow is smooth; smooth is fast. - Rich Strauss

kona_expat's picture
Posts
478
Member
1464 days
kona_expat posted 2 years ago.

I have been to them but no longer go. I have a herniated disk (L5-S1), and I could be going 3x a week, but I fixed myself. Thing is, the vertebra and other bones get out of position because a MUSCLE is pulling them that way (which can lead to a herniation--increase the space between 2 vertebrae and the disc can pop out). And then one tight muscle leads to another, and another and another, and pretty soon you can barely walk because you are now in pain.

I did research and found a book that helped me overcome sciatica and that combined with a good stretching program, keeps me in great condition. The Trigger Point Therapy Workbook by Clair Davies. Basically you hunt down and then work on trigger points (isolated tight spots within muscles), and you'd start with the one causing the acute pain, and then you keep looking, since there are probably other muscles involved.

With the low back, sitting a lot is really bad and causes all sorts of trouble--hamstrings, glutes, and then low back gets involved. So to fix everything can take awhile, but you can certainly relieve the acute stuff in a few weeks if you are diligent. I did this and have not been back to a chiropractor, have increased my ROM everywhere in my body, and feel wonderful.

You can't go wrong with a $20 book. It just might be the thing that makes the difference.

qb ant's picture
Posts
612
Member
1438 days
qb ant posted 2 years ago.

Thanks for all the input guys. Thanks Kona, I'm going to order the book from Amazon. I knew it was muscular because it's bad in the morning, but once I'm up and "warmed" up I feel good. I started doing yoga about a month ago, and that seems to be helping. I've been constantly on the lookout for new stretches that reach the areas I need to be reached. I think the book will help.

Thanks again - Ant :)

"90% of the game is half mental" Yogi Berra

bpsgson's picture
Posts
9
Member
1287 days
bpsgson posted 2 years ago.

The not so million dollar question. As a physical therapist I get the question all the time. My answer has always been the same ... there are good chiropractors and bad ones, just like in any other profession (trust me there are some plenty of bad PTs out there). What I often tell people is that they need to be educated consumers of the medical field. Most soft tissue injuries heal in 4-8 weeks if the right things are done and the stresses taken off the tissue. If someone tells you that you need to sign on for 3x/week for a year, I would be suspicious. Also, ask a lot of why questions, such as "Why is my back out of alignment". If you constantly need manipulation, it would tell me that someone has never taught you to what to do to maintain "alignment". Whoever you chose to see should be able to give you a biomechanical cause and effect relationship to your pain that you understand. If not, I would caution you to check elsewhere. Treat the cause of the problem = permanent cure, treat the symptoms and often the effect is only temporary. Best of luck and feel free to write if you have any questions.