Dented Frame
Unless there is visble cracking around the dent and the nearby bottom bracket it shloudnt be a concern.
I ahve a similar issue on an old Connondale r500 frame that I still ride for training and it hasnt been an issue in the past 5 years.
Yes, it will only be a concern when the dent fatigues and stresses during a decent down a hill....
I wouldnt ride it if it was dented, any kind of stress under the paint/clearcoat can be unseen and there for cause a huge disaster later on....just my .02
The strength of the Down tube with a dent depends on the thickness of the tubing Klein used in the bikes manufacture. I did some research and couldn't find what they were using at the time. It MIGHT be alright, but remember that the DT is the most stressed tube on the bike. I'm concerned with other components that might be damaged...you say it looks like the small ring was the cause of the dent...that means that all sorts of torqueing was involved to make that happen....it may have weakened the bottom bracket and god knows what else...I wouldn't ride it. If it were steel , yeah, but not aluminium.
If you decide to keep it keep a close eye on it. You might also be able to pick up a great used frame and switch over the grouppo.
Good luck!
"A little nonsense now and then is cherished by the wisest men."
i've had a dent in my top tube for 3 years of training and racing and commuting
If its aluminum, any qualified welder should be able to tig a patch over the dent to maintain your frames structural integrity.
Jeff
Might wanna make sure that that dent is not there by manufacturer spec. Klein has been owned by Trek for a while, and a lot of Trek bikes are built with that indentation there to allow for front derailleur travel. Unless your frame is tweaked big time, there is really no other way for that dent to get there. If there is not scratches or breaks in the paint, my money is on that dent being there by design.
Life is short. Play hard and get dirty doing it.
Might wanna make sure that that dent is not there by manufacturer spec. Klein has been owned by Trek for a while, and a lot of Trek bikes are built with that indentation there to allow for front derailleur travel. Unless your frame is tweaked big time, there is really no other way for that dent to get there. If there is not scratches or breaks in the paint, my money is on that dent being there by design.
Good call! I think you might be onto something...
"A little nonsense now and then is cherished by the wisest men."
Thanks for all of the responses. I guess there is a chance that I just did not notice it. I have been thinking more about it, and if it was dented while I was riding there should be some scratches or I would have heard something. While I have overlooked things before, I don't know how I could have overlooked something that is so painfully obviously now. I tried to find information on the frame, and all I could find was the geometry, components information.
Triguy, could you try to describe the design dent, since that is sounding like what my "problem" is?
Thanks again any information is very appreciated, and if it turns out to be a design thing, I'm sorry about my dumb thread
I just went and looked at my Trek 2300. Guess what is there right in the proximity of the FD? With the FD in the little ring, there is just enough clearance there to fit a finger tip back there and feel the indentation, its more accessible with the FD in the big ring. It is smooth and sort of vertical oval shaped.
Life is short. Play hard and get dirty doing it.
From the Zenn master (someone with far mroe authority than me:)
http://www.velonews.com/article/7728
Last letter/ response.
Life is short. Play hard and get dirty doing it.
having studied a bit of material science for my Chem E degree I'm not to scared. However, if this dent is enough to cause a structural failure, the bike will simply fold up one day while you ride it. That being said, anything structural is over designed by many factors (i.e. it is 2,3,4,5X as strong as it needs to be). I know many TT bikes out there that have dents and have been raced hard for years. unless the tube folds under the stress of your training rides, or is getting worse, I wouldn't worry about it. Go ride it hard, flex it with whatever force you can put on it with your hands, if nothing happens, race it! If it folds up like an old map, then hang it in your garage and tell stories about the bike that you folded up.
"Thanks again any information is very appreciated, and if it turns out to be a design thing, I'm sorry about my dumb thread."
Are you kidding! This is the kind of stuff that frame geeks (and I use that term with all due respect) drool over! You just sent every Trek owner out there running to the basement or garage to check out their bike. ( Hell, I ran to the basement to check out my bikes!) It's a cool question and while the answers you get here at trifuel might be dumb...the questions never are.
Good luck and I hope it never 'folds up" on you during a 60 mph descent...
"A little nonsense now and then is cherished by the wisest men."
Thanks a lot for all of the responses. I'm just going to keep riding it, and I shouldn't have to worry about the frame folding on 60mph descents in Baton rouge. The biggest hill on my training ride is from the top of the levy to the bottom of the levy.












I have a 9 year old Klein Quantam, and yesterday when I was riding it, I noticed a dent. The dent is on the crank side of the downtube, and it looks like my 39 ring just came in and pushed in on the downtube about 1/4th of an inch. The tube is still straight. Replacing the frame isn't really an option since they aren't made anymore, and since I am really poor. So I was wondering if anyone had experience riding a bike with a dented frame, and if anyone has an idea how this happened.